What is the difference between actual cash value and replacement cost?
Plain-English summary
Replacement cost pays what it would cost to repair or replace damaged property with new property of similar kind and quality. Actual cash value pays replacement cost minus depreciation, so it usually pays less for older items.
The explanation
Say a covered fire destroys a sofa you bought years ago. A replacement cost policy pays toward a comparable new sofa. An actual cash value policy pays what the old sofa was worth, taking wear and age into account.
Many homeowners policies insure the house on a replacement cost basis and may cover belongings on either basis. Some insurers first pay actual cash value and then pay the rest of the replacement cost after you actually repair or replace the item.
It depends on your policy
- Which method applies to your home and to your belongings is set by your policy.
- Some items or roofs may be settled on actual cash value even under a replacement cost policy.
- Your coverage limit still caps what the insurer pays.
What to ask your agent
- Are my home and belongings covered for replacement cost or actual cash value?
- Do I have to replace an item before I get the full replacement cost?
- Is my roof covered differently?
Sources
- NAIC Glossary of Insurance Terms (opens in a new tab)
- Missouri Department of Insurance glossary (opens in a new tab)
- Triple-I (Insurance Information Institute): Your renters insurance guide (opens in a new tab)
Sources checked Nov 19, 2026. Where a state agency is cited, its guidance is an example for that state; rules in your state may differ.
Related on this site
Glossary terms
Related questions
Disclaimer: These answers are general, plain-English information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Coverage depends on your policy wording, your insurer and your state’s laws, which control. Always read your policy and confirm with your agent, your insurer or your state insurance department.