InsuranceReference.org

Mennonite Mutual Claims Phone Number & Contact Info

Quick answer

Verify before use · Last reviewed Nov 19, 2026 · How we check

Claims

By phone

Claims department
1-330-682-2986

Online

More claims contacts (2)
Main fax (fax)
1-330-683-2083

Sources: mennonitemutual.com · mennonitemutual.com

How to file a claim with Mennonite Mutual — claims numbers, official filing links, and a short checklist.

Contact

Customer service & billing

Main telephone number
1-330-682-2986

Online

Sources: mennonitemutual.com

Company info

Legal name
Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company
NAIC group code
4780
NAIC group name
MENNONITE MUT GRP
Address listed on company website
1000 South Main Street, Orrville, OH 44667
Founded
1895
Structure
Ohio mutual property insurer for farms and faith-based organizations
NAIC statement types
Property & Casualty
AM Best
Licensed data, not shown. Look it up on ambest.com ↗
Show 1 writing company

Names as abbreviated in NAIC market share reports ("INS CO" = Insurance Company), with each company's NAIC code. Look one up on NAIC Consumer Insurance Search ↗.

MENNONITE MUT INS CO
17299 P&C

Sources: content.naic.org · mennonitemutual.com

History

Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company, based at 1000 South Main Street in Orrville, Ohio, has provided coverage for farms and faith-based organizations since J.M. Smucker founded the company in 1895, according to its site. The contact and claims pages list a main telephone number, a fax number, and a claims email address.

Sources: Mennonite Mutual · Mennonite Mutual: Contact us · Mennonite Mutual: Claims. Summarized in our own words.

FAQ

What is the Mennonite Mutual claims phone number?

Claims department: 1-330-682-2986. Confirm the number on your policy documents, because claims lines can vary by policy and state.

What is the Mennonite Mutual customer service phone number?

Main telephone number: 1-330-682-2986.

What is the NAIC code for Mennonite Mutual?

Mennonite Mutual's NAIC group code is 4780. Each insurer in the group also has its own five-digit NAIC company code; 1 are listed on this page.

Before you call or send anything: Phone numbers, links, and addresses change. We list only customer-facing contacts that we found on the company's own website (or, for identifiers, in NAIC or SEC records) on the date shown, and each one links to its source. Before you send documents, payments, or a claim, confirm the contact on your policy documents, ID card, or the company's website. InsuranceReference.org is an independent reference site. We are not affiliated with or endorsed by any company listed, we do not handle claims, and nothing here is legal or coverage advice.

Is something missing or incorrect?